Mayor Distributes
A Detailed Memo
Defending Transfer
BY AMY
ROSE
STAFF WRITER
Members of the
Greeneville Board of Mayor and Aldermen continue to try to coordinate their calendars to schedule a
workshop meeting to discuss the still-controversial transfer of Department of Parks and Recreation
maintenance employees to the Department of Public Works.
No date for such
a workshop has been set at this time, but it is expected to be scheduled
soon.
Meanwhile, Mayor Laraine King distributed to other members of the
Board of Mayor and Aldermen this week a lengthy, detailed memo explaining and defending her decision
to move the employees.
The controversy developed some 15 months ago when
Mayor King, acting in her capacity as the town's top elected official, transferred the maintenance
employees from the Parks and Recreation Department to the Department of Public
Works.
The action was not brought before the full Board of Mayor and
Aldermen.
Since then, critics of the move -- including Aldermen W.T.
Daniels, Buddy Hawk and Sarah Webster, and members of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board --
have questioned the legality of the transfer and said that they thought the action should have been
considered by the full board.
The mayor has maintained that transferring
employees between town departments was within her authority and responsibility as the senior
official of the town government.
She has also emphasized that the
transfer has saved a significant amount of money for the town.
At the
conclusion of the Nov. 3 board meeting, Alderman Hawk asked when a workshop was going to be
held.
Mayor King said she has not been able to schedule a time when
everyone could attend.
The board said all members of the Parks and
Recreation Advisory Board also need to be notified when a workshop is
scheduled.
MAYOR KING'S MEMO
After the
discussion, Mayor King gave each alderman a packet of information supporting her decision to make
the transfer. (See related article.)
The packet included a five-page memo
that stated, in part:
"It appears that the stakeholders in this
discussion have not been able to arrange an agreeable schedule for a discussion. This discussion is
significant because it is distracting us from pursuing the many important concerns affecting our
town."
King also stated in the memo that she had the authority to make
the transfer because the Town Charter calls for the mayor to have general supervision over all
employees.
"The issue for discussion," she wrote in the memo, "is whether
or not the decision I made, to transfer the supervision of the maintenance crew from the director of
Parks and Recreation to the director of Public Works, was justified by the facts which I found when
I was elected mayor, and by the results supported by the facts which have developed since that
time."
The memo also stated, "If you have any disagreement with the facts
as I have presented them, please put them in writing to me within one week, and I will then schedule
a workshop to address them."
MANY DOCUMENTS INCLUDED
Attached to the memo were the following documents:
*
lists of capital expenses since 2004 in the Parks and Recreation
Department;
* a list of employees who have left the town's employment
since Jan. 1, 2008;
* a six-year review of overtime expense by
department;
* the town's expenditure reports since
2004;
* Parks and Recreation Department fuel consumption expense over the
past three years;
* payroll information for the maintenance
workers;
* wage totals for the last three years in the Parks and
Recreation Department;
* account information related to concessions,
games and league entry fees;
* a list of the 33 town properties currently
maintained by the Department of Public Works and descriptions of that
maintenance;
* a four-page list of major improvements made to those
properties; and
* a copy of a letter dated April 28, 2009, from Town
Recorder Jim Warner to Butch Patterson, director of the Parks and Recreation Department, outlining
changes in revenues and expenditures since the transfer was made.
The
results of comparisons of these documents are included in King's memo.
HIGHLIGHTS OF MEMO
According to the memo, the financial
information shows that:
"Fuel use for building, grounds, and maintenance
crew decreased 2,321.5 gallons during the year; an improvement of 39.23
percent.
* "Maintenance worker hours of work decreased, saving $47,658.88
during the year; an improvement of 14.46 percent.
* "Overtime charges for
maintenance workers decreased approximately $3,109.25 during the year compared to previous fiscal
year; an improvement of 80.79 percent.
* "Basketball concessions, gate
receipts, and fees increased $14,462.00 for the two-month season, an improvement of 20.88
percent.
* "Andrew Johnson School basketball goals were fixed after years
of neglect, requests for replacement dating from 2005-06 budget, and serious safety
concerns.
* "More work done at more places during 2008-09 year by
combined crews under new management. Many more capital projects completed than in previous year.
Nine projects completed in 2007-08. Eighty-two projects completed in 2008-09; an improvement of 911
percent.
* "Parks and Recreation budget in the black 2009, first time
since 2003-04."
Mayor King for some time has been stating that the
transfer has saved the town an estimated $100,000.
In her packet of
information, the letter from Warner to Patterson states that, for the Parks and Recreation
Department, revenues were up $34,429.75, and expenditures were down
$65,746.78.